Creativity and Depression: What Causes the Link?

The World Health Organization estimates that over 121 million people worldwide suffer from some form of depression. It is one of the world's most common mental disorders, with 30 percent of sufferers attempting suicide. I'm not lying when I say depression kills.

Creative types have been proven to be the group most affected by this disorder, with people such as Ernest Hemingway, Virginia Woolf, and Michelangelo all being affected. Is this due to nothing but their unique thought processes, or could it be something else?

It has been proven that as a species, human beings are drawn to those with whom we share ideas and have similar thoughts. Studies have shown this time and time again, such as in Newcomb's 1956 experiment where he found that men liked their housemates more if they had similar attitudes about sex, family, and politics. This is because people enjoy feeling validated, are impressed when others have the same taste as them, and find it easier to talk to those with the same interests.

So it is reasonable to assume that if a person is unable to find someone with a similar thought process to them, they will become lonely and may end up suffering from depression. Creative people have the most unique of minds, and therefore we can draw the conclusion that as cliched as it sounds, no one understands them.

However, Newcomb's study was flawed in many ways; its gender bias and small sample size of 17 mean that it can't be generalized to the entire population, and it fails to explore deeper levels of thought. This means that while people may be more agreeable when they have the same views, it doesn't mean those with different views are shunned from society.

So what does cause such levels of depression in the more creative half of the population? Akinola and Mendes in 2008 conducted a study that looked at the role of rejection when it comes to creativity. Participants were given either positive, negative, or no feedback on a speaking test and then asked to produce a collage. The participants exposed to negative feedback or rejection produced more creative collages than participants in the control group and the positive feedback group. This suggests that societal rejection, a particular symptom of depression, may be responsible for increased creativity.

In other words, depression causes creativity instead of creativity causing depression. It is crucial to think critically when it comes to the art in order to reach your optimum capability, but the problem with overthinking is that self-doubt often follows and with that lower confidence making it easier to slip into depression.

Perhaps the cause of such mental issues with creative people is that they get too used to judging their own work and slowly begin judging themselves. I know that I am guilty of doing this as it becomes hard to distinguish between the two especially when you put so much heart into what you're working on, it almost becomes a part of you.

The role of an artist is to always dance on the dangerous line, and for many, the dance is too hard to keep up. Do you suffer from the same struggles which theory do you support depression causing creativity or creativity causing depression?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How Sleep Positions Affect Nightmares and Dream Quality

Image
Many people are aware that sleep positions significantly affect sleep quality and comfort during the night, but not everyone knows that certain sleep positions may also increase the likelihood of experiencing nightmares. The Link Between Sleep Positions and Dreams Theresa Cheung, a dream interpretation expert and bestselling author, suggests that sleep positions can indeed influence the nature of our dreams. Although everyone dreams regardless of how they sleep, studies indicate that sleeping on the right side may lead to more emotionally expressive and healing dreams compared to sleeping on the left side, which has been linked to an increased likelihood of nightmares. This is potentially due to the added pressure on the heart when sleeping on the left side, which can lead to poorer sleep quality and a higher incidence of nightmares. Cheung explains that while left-side sleepers might be more prone to nightmares, those who sleep on their backs are also more likely to experience t
Read more

Knife Angel: A Monument Against Violence

Image
The Knife Angel, also known as the National Monument Against Violence & Aggression, is a powerful contemporary sculpture created by British artist Alfie Bradley. Standing at 27 feet (8.2 meters) tall, this striking piece is made from over 100,000 knives collected from amnesty bins and police seizures across the United Kingdom. Creation and Purpose The Knife Angel was completed in 2018 at the British Ironworks Centre in Oswestry, England. The project aimed to raise awareness about the devastating effects of knife crime and to serve as a memorial for those who have lost their lives to such violence. The sculpture was constructed using knives that were disinfected and blunted before being welded onto a steel frame to form the angel's body and wings. Community Involvement Families who have been affected by knife crime were invited to engrave personal messages onto the blades used in the sculpture. Over 80 families participated, adding a deeply emotional and pe
Read more

The Dancing Plague of 1518

Image
The Dancing Plague of 1518, also known as the Dance Epidemic, is one of history's most peculiar and baffling events. It occurred in the city of Strasbourg, France (then part of the Holy Roman Empire), and saw dozens of people dancing uncontrollably for days on end. The phenomenon remains largely unexplained, but it has captured the imagination of historians and researchers for centuries. This article explores the details of the event, the possible causes, and its lasting impact. Historical Context of the Dancing Plague In July 1518, a woman named Frau Troffea began dancing fervently in the streets of Strasbourg. She danced for several hours without stopping, and within a week, dozens of others had joined her. Reports suggest that at its peak, around 400 people were affected by the urge to dance. These individuals danced continuously for days, some even collapsing from exhaustion, and a few reportedly died from heart attacks, strokes, or sheer fatigue. Strasbourg in the Early
Read more